Navigating Defect Claims: The Role of Expert Valuation

Defects are often the most contentious and most expensive part of a construction dispute.

When things go wrong on site, assigning blame is only the first step. The bigger challenge is establishing the value of the defect claim. Whether you’re representing an employer, contractor, or designer and independent expert valuation is crucial.

Why is Defect Valuation So Complex?

• Costs are forward-looking and often disputed

• Scope of rectification can vary widely

• Insurance and liability positions may hinge on the valuation

• Opinions from both sides often differ significantly

Where Expert Valuation Helps

1. Assessing Remedial Works

   • We evaluate the most reasonable method of rectification and cost it using current rates and benchmarks.

2. Loss of Use / Consequential Loss

   • We help quantify downstream financial impacts, where applicable.

3. Contractual Interpretation

   • Tying valuation back to contract obligations and warranties.

4. Mitigation

   • Calculating how costs can or should have been reduced by reasonable steps.

Typical Claims We Assist With:

• Defective cladding or roofing

• Structural movement or cracking

• Faulty M&E installations

• Poor-quality finishes or non-compliant works

How We Work

• Site inspection and documentation review

• Detailed valuation report

• Support through negotiations, adjudication, or litigation

• CPR Part 35-compliant expert witness reports if needed

Conclusion

Defect claims can become battlegrounds but independent, expert valuation provides clarity and objectivity. We help all parties understand the real cost of putting things right.

Click here if you need clarity on the true value of a defect claim?